top of page

Research: Do USA gun buybacks actually reduce gun crime?

11 minutes ago
5 min read

Data reviewed: Ferrazares, Sabia and Anderson, "Have U.S. gun buyback programs misfired?", Journal of Policy Analysis and Management (September 2025) and NBER Working Paper 28763 (revised December 2022); City of Rockville gun buyback information (November 2026); Office of the Auditor-General, firearms buy-back and amnesty reports (2020 and 2022).

Gun buybacks are often presented as a simple way to cut gun violence: pay people to hand in firearms, destroy them, and there are fewer guns to misuse. The largest study of American city buybacks found no sign that it works. Economists Toshio Ferrazares, Joseph Sabia and Mark Anderson examined 339 buybacks held in 277 US cities between 1991 and 2015 and found no evidence that they reduced gun crime, firearm homicides or firearm suicides. Their published paper says that, with 95 percent confidence, any drop in firearm crime in the year after a buyback was no greater than 1.2 percent. Their explanation is plain: the people who hand in guns are mostly low-risk owners, and the guns tend to be older and less functional. COLFO has lodged an Official Information Act request with Police asking for any evaluation of the buy-backs and updated figures on prohibited firearms seized. COLFO is looking at international research and trends to grow its reference library, so licensed firearm owners can use our site to find reliable information from around the world.


COLFO members get more

      Want to read more?

      Subscribe to colfo.org to keep reading this exclusive post.

      STAY INFORMED

       Get the Latest News, Consultation Guidelines, and  PR Updates Free

      I am a member of the following (optional)

      Thanks for signing up!

      ADDRESS

      PO Box 532,

      Wellington 6140

      EMAIL

      FACEBOOK

      • Facebook logo
      • X

      © 2023 by Purple Thread Digital. 

      bottom of page